Automation allows mid-tier accounting firms to provide higher value services
Clients who might previously have looked towards the Big 4 or second tier firms for business consulting projects have an alternative. And most importantly, they will be able to get the service from professionals who already know their business and with whom they have a long-standing relationship. - Introducing the small 4 (thousand).
Introducing the small 4 (thousand)
Discussion of artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning technologies tends to provoke a range of responses from dismissal to dread and anxiety at what the so-called rise of the robots will do to the employment landscape in the coming years.
133 – 75 = 58,000,000 new jobs
The more sanguine analysts point to the various optimistic reports such as The Future of Jobs 2018 produced by the World Economic Forum (WEF). This report predicted that machines and algorithms in the workplace will create 133 million new jobs, but cause 75 million losses by 2022 – meaning a net gain of 58 million jobs over the next few years.
That’s very comforting if you are on the right side of that gain line. Pretty bleak if you are not, however.
"Robots and algorithms won’t be designed to do particular jobs or take over specific roles, they will carry out individual tasks and elements of tasks".
But things aren’t quite that clear-cut. They never are. Robots and algorithms won’t be designed to do particular jobs or take over specific roles, they will carry out individual tasks and elements of tasks. And the impact will be much more nuanced than many anticipate.
For example, the same report found that nearly 50 per cent of all companies are expecting their full-time workforce to shrink by 2022 due to automation, but 40 per cent are expecting to grow their workforce while more than 25 per cent are expecting the technology to lead to the creation of new roles in their organisations.
Where those new roles will come from?
The facile answer is that new roles will return as a result of increased demand for products and services generated by economic growth. This growth, in turn, has been fuelled by the efficiencies and cost savings delivered by the new technologies.
If only everything was so simple. Those same savings and efficiencies could drive smaller less well-resourced players out of business as their products and services become increasingly commoditised. There are no real winners in a race to the bottom, after all.
Don’t inadvertently enter into a race to the bottom
The challenge, therefore, is not to get involved in the race yet still emerge a winner. By all means utilise the technology to take out costs and become more productive, but don’t get caught in the death spiral of ever decreasing margins.
That way lies obsolescence; where basic accountancy service offerings go the way of the pocket calculator. When was the last time you saw one of those outside of a Christmas cracker? The smartphone has killed that market.
The choice for smaller accountancy firms
One option sees small firms jettison all costs, including people, in the pursuit of efficiencies and short-term competitiveness. The other involves taking a risk and searching for new market opportunities which will assuredly arise as a result of the technology.
That risk begins with how the investment in the technology is viewed. Is the return on the investment to be delivered through cost reductions or business growth? The latter may be more uncertain but is also the option with most potential.
The technology will automate the more repetitive tasks currently undertaken by trainee and junior accountants. It will soon automate many of the more routine tasks carried out by more senior professionals as well.
What should be done with the time saved from using automation?
The old-fashioned answer would be to make staff redundant and bank the salary savings. The courageous one is to invest even more money in the training and up skilling of those staff to enable them to take on higher value tasks.
And the secret powers that automation delivers...
The other side of the technological coin is the vast quantities of usable data it will put in the hands of accounting professionals.
The same algorithms that replace the routine tasks will gather unstructured data and make it available for analysis which can then be used to deliver business insights to clients.
Small and medium sized accounting firms will be able to add high value advisory and consultancy to their service offerings. But only if they have the staff to do so – staff with those irreplaceable human qualities of critical and strategic thinking and relationship building.
Clients who might previously have looked towards the Big 4 or second tier firms for business consulting projects will have an alternative. And most importantly, they will be able to get the service from professionals who already know their business and with whom they have a long-standing relationship.
This has the potential to transform and democratise the consulting and advisory landscape. Firms of all sizes will be able to compete against the very biggest based on the quality and ingenuity of their employees rather than their scale. They might specialise in discrete service offerings and form alliances with other specialists to deliver more comprehensive offerings when required. And this will all be driven and facilitated by the technology which might previously have been seen as a threat to the viability and very existence of these firms.
Instead of the Big 4, it might be the case of the Small 4,000.
This video illustrates some of the above nicely.
AutoEntry - an accountant's secret weapon
AutoEntry helps accountants around the world automate their work and broaden their offering to clients. Find out how with a free trial.